Are freight railroads putting profits ahead of worker safety? New research raises troubling questions about the consequences of cost-cutting—and what injured railroad workers need to know about their FELA rights.
Freight railroad companies want to move more freight, reduce operating expenses, and improve profitability. But when those goals drive decisions about staffing, train length, equipment, and working conditions, an important question arises: Who pays the price when increased profits come at the expense of safety?
A newly published study in the International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management brings that question into sharp focus.
The August 2026 study, “Operational improvement at the expense of safety? An analysis of precision scheduled railroading implementation”, examines Precision Scheduled Railroading (PSR) and its relationship to operating performance and safety across major U.S. freight railroads.
The researchers found that PSR was associated with operational efficiency gains, including longer trains, greater locomotive utilization, and workforce reductions. But those gains were accompanied by higher derailment and accident rates.
For railroad workers, these findings raise serious concerns about whether the industry’s drive to reduce costs and maximize profits adequately accounts for the safety of the people doing the work.
For railroad workers injured because of railroad negligence, the consequences can be life-changing.
What Is Precision Scheduled Railroading—and Why Does It Matter?
Precision Scheduled Railroading is an operating strategy adopted by major freight railroads to reduce costs, improve asset utilization, and increase operating efficiency.
PSR is commonly associated with:
- Reducing railroad staffing and labor expenses.
- Operating longer freight trains.
- Increasing the utilization of locomotives and other equipment.
- Reducing the number of assets needed to move freight.
These changes improve financial performance and make Wall Street investors happy. However, the safety implications can be significant without safeguards remain in place.
A 2022 report from the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) found that staffing across the seven largest U.S. freight railroads declined by approximately 28% between 2011 and 2021. All seven railroads also reported running longer trains.
The GAO documented concerns raised by railroad unions, employees, and safety inspectors about staffing reductions, fatigue, training, longer trains, and equipment maintenance. The new 2026 research adds important evidence to this ongoing debate.
The central concern is straightforward: When cost reduction becomes a dominant operating objective, are railroads doing enough to protect the workers?
How Can Railroad Cost-Cutting Affect Worker Safety?
Railroad work is physically demanding and often hazardous. Conductors, locomotive engineers, track workers, repair shop workers, mechanical employees, signal department workers, and other railroad personnel depend on appropriate training, safe equipment, adequate staffing, and workable safety procedures.
Changes to railroad operations can affect these protections in several ways:
- Railroad job cuts and increased workloads
When a railroad reduces its workforce, remaining workers often face increased workloads or different demands on their time. Depending on the circumstances, that can affect the time available to complete inspections, make repairs to tracks and equipment, and follow safety procedures.
The relevant question is not simply how many workers a railroad has eliminated. It is whether the remaining workforce can perform assigned duties safely under the actual working conditions.
- Longer trains and operational risks
Longer freight trains present operational challenges that require appropriate planning, equipment, inspections, and procedures.
When an accident occurs, the train’s length may be one factor worth investigating alongside equipment condition, maintenance history, operating practices, and the circumstances of the incident.
A long train does not automatically establish negligence. However, railroad operating decisions should not escape scrutiny simply because they were intended to improve efficiency.
- Fatigue and demanding schedules
Railroad employees often work irregular hours, overnight assignments, and schedules that make adequate rest difficult. Staffing and scheduling decisions can affect fatigue risks, depending on the circumstances.
Fatigue can impair attention, judgment, and reaction time—all critical abilities in safety-sensitive railroad work.
An investigation into a railroad injury may therefore need to examine the employee’s schedule, workload, opportunity for rest, and compliance with applicable safety requirements.
These issues deserve more than a spreadsheet measuring operating costs. They deserve a serious examination of how railroad management decisions affect the people working on the tracks, in the yards, and aboard trains.
When Railroad Companies Put Profits Ahead of Safety, Injured Workers Need Answers
The pursuit of profitability is not, by itself, proof of wrongdoing. Nor does the 2026 study establish that every railroad operating under PSR is negligent or that every workplace injury results from cost-cutting.
But the study raises a troubling fact: operational improvements may come with safety consequences that deserve greater attention.
For injured railroad employees, the important issue is whether specific management decisions, unsafe working conditions, or failures to address known hazards contributed to their injuries.
For example, an investigation might examine whether:
- The railroad failed to provide a reasonably safe place to work.
- Inadequate maintenance contributed to an equipment or track defect.
- Unsafe staffing or supervision contributed to hazardous working conditions.
- An employee received inadequate training.
- A known safety hazard was ignored or left uncorrected.
The evidence matters. Work assignments, inspection records, maintenance histories, safety reports, training records, and witness accounts may help establish what happened and why.
When a railroad’s negligence contributes to an employee’s injury, the company should be held accountable under the law.
How FELA Protects Injured Railroad Workers
The Federal Employers’ Liability Act, commonly known as FELA, provides a legal avenue for covered railroad employees to seek compensation for injuries caused in whole or in part by railroad negligence.
Under 45 U.S.C. § 51, a covered railroad employer may be liable for an employee’s injury resulting in whole or in part from negligence by the railroad, or from specified defects or insufficiencies in equipment, tools or property.
Unlike a typical state workers’ compensation claim, a FELA case generally requires the injured employee to establish railroad negligence and its connection to the injury.
Depending on the facts, a successful FELA claim may provide compensation for:
- Past and future medical expenses.
- Lost wages and diminished future earning capacity.
- Physical pain and suffering.
- Mental and emotional suffering.
- Other legally recoverable damages supported by the evidence.
Not every railroad injury qualifies for compensation, and the outcome depends on the circumstances and applicable law.
However, injured railroad workers should not assume that an accident was simply an unavoidable part of the job. If unsafe conditions, defective equipment, inadequate training, or other negligent conduct played a role, a FELA attorney can help evaluate the available evidence and explain the employee’s options.
Injured While Working for a Railroad? Protect Your FELA Rights.
If you have been injured while working for a freight railroad, you may be dealing with medical bills, lost income, uncertainty about your future, and pressure to return to work.
You should not have to navigate those challenges without understanding your legal rights.
An experienced FELA railroad injury lawyer can investigate the circumstances of your accident, assess potential evidence of negligence, explain what compensation may be available, and help you understand the deadlines that apply to your claim.
FELA generally has a three-year statute of limitations, although the applicable deadline depends on the circumstances of the claim. Seeking legal advice promptly can help protect important evidence and your ability to pursue a claim.
Railroad Companies Must Be Held Accountable When Negligence Causes Injuries
The 2026 research on Precision Scheduled Railroading (PSR) raises an important question for the freight railroad industry: Are efficiency and profitability receiving greater attention than the safety risks faced by railroad employees?
The reported association between PSR, operational improvements, and higher accident and derailment rates deserves serious consideration. Combined with previously documented safety concerns about staffing, fatigue, and maintenance, it reinforces the need to examine the real-world consequences of railroad operating decisions.
Railroad workers are not disposable operating expenses. Their safety matters.
If you or a family member has suffered a railroad-related injury, contact the railroad injury lawyers at Doran & Murphy to confidentially discuss your situation and learn whether you may have a claim under the FELA. You can call us at 800-374-2144 or contact us here.
We can help you understand your rights and evaluate the steps available to pursue accountability when railroad negligence causes harm. Our FELA injury attorneys have decades of experience in fighting for the rights of injured workers.



