How Could the Safety Appliance Act Strengthen a FELA Claim?
The Federal Employers Liability Act (FELA) provides railroad workers who get hurt on the job the right to hold their employers directly liable for negligence leading to their injuries. This is a privilege that is not usually afforded to workers in other industries covered by traditional workers’ compensation laws. On top of that, additional pieces of federal legislation passed since FELA first went into effect have strengthened the rights of railroad workers who are injured under specific circumstances or due to specific kinds of employer negligence.
One of the most noteworthy of these is the Safety Appliance Act, passed in 1893 in order to specifically address injuries stemming from defective safety devices. As a seasoned railroad accident lawyer could further explain, the Safety Appliance Act holds employers strictly liable for accidents of this nature rather than forcing injured workers to prove negligence during a FELA claims. This could allow for substantially greater compensation for the claimant, depending on the circumstances.
Mandates Established Under the Safety Appliance Act
Under the Safety Appliance Act, railroad employers have an absolute duty to ensure that all of their working locomotives have properly functioning safety devices installed and have safe working conditions for employees aboard. 49 Code of Federal Regulations Part 231 lists all the safety requirements incumbent upon railroad operators under this Act, but some worth highlighting in particular include the following:
- All railcars must have securely mounted running boards, ladders, sill steps, handholds, and grab irons where applicable
- All railcars must have brake systems in good working condition that allow engineers to safely and quickly slow the locomotive without having to use handbrakes
- Coupling mechanisms between railcars must couple and uncouple automatically without requiring railroad workers to manually perform either task
- Railcars must have properly installed and functional drawbars where applicable
- Walkways between railcars must be free of slipping and tripping hazards at all times
Any railroad owner, operator, or employer who fails to fulfill any requirement established by this Act may bear strict liability under FELA for any injuries suffered by a railroad worker as a direct result of that safety violation.
Defining When the Safety Appliance Act Applies to a FELA Claim
The Safety Appliance Act (SAA) does not apply to every claim filed under FELA, nor does it automatically apply when a safety mechanism fails or a violation occurs. In order for the SAA to strengthen a FELA claim, the injury in question must have occurred while the locomotive in question was “in use.”
Accordingly, the strict liability established under the SAA does not apply to injuries caused by defective safety equipment while a train is stopped for maintenance, being repaired, undergoing inspection, or out of service for any other reason. In this kind of situation, the normal rules for FELA claims would apply, meaning that an injured worker would have to prove that some form of negligence by their employer directly caused their on-the-job accident in order to be eligible for recovery.
That being said, a train does not necessarily have to be actively in motion to be considered “in use” for the purposes of the SAA. So long as the train has been approved for active service and has not yet been taken out of service, this Act would apply to any injury resulting from unsafe conditions aboard. A knowledgeable attorney could offer further clarification about this unique aspect of certain FELA claims during a private consultation.